Love One Another
San Francisco Silent Film Festival silentfilm.org
This is what was read here when it was published. Anita Monga no longer carries it in what it publishes now.
Listen to this summary
You play the cineaste game, and eventually you build an Andrew Sarris-style hierarchy, a pantheon of the great filmmakers over the long game, from 1890-whatever to the present. Limit the top tier to ten or twelve, say, and a few names from the silent era will consistently arise. Fashions come and go: decades ago, when film history was only sixty or seventy years long, Eisenstein and Chaplin might top the list, until they didn’t. In the half-century since, Griffith has long been relegated to a musty moviehead purgatory, while Murnau and Keaton remain evergreen. However your chips fall, you inevitably get to Carl Theodor Dreyer, the mysterious Dane whose name has always persisted in the top…
Except that’s actually not all there is—Dreyer’s filmography features a half dozen other silents that are, with the exception of The Parson’s Widow (1920), more or less forgotten. Few of us that aren’t seasoned Dreyerphiles will be expected to have seen or even heard of Love One Another (Die Gezeichneten, translating as The Stigmatized), made in Germany in 1922. Based on a best-selling 1918 novel by popular Danish writer Aage Madelung, it’s Dreyer’s fourth feature in as many years, and though you could say he was still developing his austere, hold-your-breath sensibility, it’s not as though the movie lacked for ambition. We’re hustled through the novelistic saga of…
More ways to use this
Open on another device
Scan to open this page. Your saved notes and account access are not included.